Courses / Commodity & FX Hedging
MTM, P&L and reporting
Marking the book against the curve, decomposing P&L into buckets that tell the truth, and the daily reports that run the desk.
Lesson 1 · free to read
Marking the book
Mark-to-market (MTM) is the daily answer to "what is every open position worth at today's market?" Its integrity rests on one rule: value each position against the market price for its own delivery date — the curve, not spot.
- Futures are easy: each contract month has a public daily settlement price; MTM per position = (settlement − book price) × lots × lot size, signed. Your internal MTM must equal the broker's statement (module 4's position/cash reconciliation is also the MTM check).
- Forwards are where the spot mistake lives. A 6-month forward marked against spot shows a phantom gain or loss equal to the forward points (module 3) on day one, which then "bleeds away" over the life — noise that looks like P&L. Correct: mark against today's forward rate for the position's maturity date (the current curve point), so day-one MTM ≈ 0 and subsequent MTM is genuine market movement. The same applies to physical commitments valued forward: use the curve for the delivery month.
- Physical positions (inventory, priced contracts) mark against the same curve as their hedges so the pair's MTM offsets honestly. A fully hedged, fully priced back-to-back marks to ~zero net — which is precisely the point; if it doesn't, the difference is basis movement or an error, and you want to know which. (What your financial accounts carry — cost-based stock, deferred hedge results under local GAAP — can legitimately differ from the desk's management MTM; both views can be right as long as each is labelled and reconciled to the other.)
Realised vs unrealised. Realised P&L is history — closed hedges, delivered cargoes, cash that moved. Unrealised MTM is the current mark on open positions and will move again tomorrow. Reports must keep the two separate and show their sum: realised-only hides the open book's truth; blended totals let a bad open position hide behind a good closed one. The daily P&L explain — yesterday's total vs today's, decomposed into new trades, price moves, closes, fees — is the desk's smoke detector: a P&L move you cannot explain is either a market event you missed or a booking error you haven't found. Both demand finding.
Marks need governance. Settlement prices for listed months are objective; curve points between prompts, illiquid back months and any interpolation are model territory. The rules — sources, interpolation, cutoff times, who may override and how overrides are logged — belong in configuration, not in a spreadsheet's muscle memory. The test of good marking is that two people running the report get the same book value, and an auditor can trace any number to a source price.
The rest of this module
- Where the P&L really comes from — the bucketsDecomposing hedged-trade P&L: trading margin, the flat-price pair and basis, funding, timing and carry — with a worked example.
- The daily reports that run the deskPosition & exposure, hedge/coverage, daily activity, exceptions, margin & cash — and reconciliation as the seal on all of it.
Carry on with the course
The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Commodity & FX Hedging Operations.
Next module: When hedging goes wrong — four case studies