Courses / Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting

Break-even and margin — forwards from the buy, backwards from the sale

Traders cost a deal both ways. The arithmetic must agree, and each cost must be counted once.

Module 3 of 73 lessonsAbout 40 minQuiz: 6 questions
Plan

Lesson 1 · free to read

Buy-led: from the purchase price to the break-even sale price

When the trader has a supplier's offer and needs to know what to sell at, it costs forwards (sometimes called bottom-up):

break-even sale price = purchase price + every cost line + time-value charge

From Modules 1 and 2:

$/t
Purchase price, FOB500.00
Freight, insurance, survey47.00
Time-value charge (55 days at 7%)5.27
Break-even sale price, CIF552.27

Selling at $552.27/t CIF earns nothing. Everything above it is margin. The trader then adds the margin it wants, either as an amount per tonne or as a mark-up on cost:

552.27 × (1 + 3%) = $568.84/t CIF for a 3% mark-up.

Mark-up and margin are different percentages of different bases. A 3% mark-up on cost is 16.57 / 568.84 = 2.91% margin on sales. Agree which one the desk means; a target of "3%" read the wrong way shifts every price.

The sale side can add costs too. Sales commission, a customer rebate or a credit-insurance premium on the receivable are costs of the sale. They belong in the stack like any other line, usually as a percentage of the sale price, so they grow with the price you are solving for. A screen that adds them after the mark-up understates the break-even.

The rest of this module

  1. Sell-led: from the sale price back to the most you can pay
    Start from what the customer will pay, take the costs off, and solve for the purchase price.
  2. Count each cost once, in one currency, and test the sensitivity
    Gross profit and 'profit after finance' can be the same number reached two ways. Do not deduct finance twice.

Carry on with the course

The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting.

Next module: Planned against actual — accruals and the deal P&L