Courses / Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting
Planned against actual — accruals and the deal P&L
The planned margin is a promise. Accrual accounting is how you find out whether it was kept.
Lesson 1 · free to read
Accrual accounting: record it when it happens, not when the cash moves
Cash accounting records a transaction when money moves. Accrual accounting records it when the economic event happens, whether or not cash has moved. Every company that produces proper financial statements uses accruals, and a trading business could not measure a deal's margin any other way.
Two principles do the work:
- Revenue is recognised when control of the goods passes to the customer. For most physical trades that follows the Incoterm and the contract: on an FOB or CIF sale, typically when the goods are loaded on board and the bill of lading is issued; on a DAP sale, when they are delivered at the named place. Not when the invoice is paid.
- Costs are matched to the revenue they produce. Freight, insurance, survey and duty on the goods sold belong in the same period as the sale, even if their invoices arrive next month.
Why a trader cannot use cash accounting. A deal loads in March. Freight is paid in March, the customer pays in May, the survey invoice arrives in June. On a cash basis March shows a loss, May a large profit, June a small loss: three wrong numbers and no deal margin. On an accrual basis the whole margin lands in March, where the sale happened.
The accrual entry. At month-end the freight invoice for a March shipment has not arrived. The freight desk's estimate is $45,000:
| Account | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of sales, freight (goods sold) | 45,000 | |
| Accrued freight (liability) | 45,000 |
In April the invoice arrives for $46,100:
| Account | Dr | Cr |
|---|---|---|
| Accrued freight | 45,000 | |
| Cost of sales, freight (the difference) | 1,100 | |
| Accounts payable | 46,100 |
The accrued freight account is now back to zero for this deal. The $1,100 lands in April, unless the books for March are still open, in which case it should go to March. If the goods were still in stock rather than sold, the debit would go to inventory instead of cost of sales (Module 5).
Two accrual cousins: a prepayment is the reverse (cash paid before the cost belongs to a period: Dr prepayment, released later), and deferred revenue is cash received before the goods are delivered (a liability until control passes).
The rest of this module
- The deal P&L from estimate to closedEstimated, contracted, accrued, actual, closed: each cost line moves through them at its own pace.
- Margin floors and exception reports that mean somethingOne flat floor across every kind of deal flags the wrong deals and misses the right ones.
Carry on with the course
The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting.
Next module: Allocating trade costs to trades — into the stock, or into the period