Courses / Commodity & FX Hedging

Margin, brokers and funding the hedge

Initial margin, variation margin, margin calls — the cash machinery that keeps hedges alive, and the broker relationships behind it.

Module 6 of 143 lessonsAbout 40 minQuiz: 6 questions
HedgeFinance

Lesson 1 · free to read

Margin mechanics — a worked week

Futures positions run on two kinds of margin, and confusing them is the fastest way to misread a broker statement.

Initial margin (IM) is a good-faith deposit per open position, set by the clearing house from the contract's volatility (via its risk model — SPAN and its successors) and typically a low single-digit percent of contract value. It is your money, parked: returned when the position closes. Brokers may charge a premium over exchange minimums.

Variation margin (VM) is the daily settlement of P&L: every day your open positions are marked to the settlement price and the difference moves in cash. A loss is taken from your account that day; a gain arrives that day. VM is not a deposit — it is realised profit and loss changing hands.

A worked week — LME lead. A metals desk is short 40 lots of LME lead (25 MT per lot, so 1,000 MT) at $2,400/MT, hedging purchased inventory. IM is $4,000/lot → $160,000 posted. One lot moves $25 per $1/MT.

  • Day 1: settle $2,410 (+$10 against the short). VM = 40 × 25 × $10 = $10,000 out.
  • Day 2: settle $2,450 (+$40). VM = $40,000 out. Account equity now dips below the required IM level and the broker issues a margin call: restore the account, in cash, by their deadline (typically same day). Note the physical inventory has gained roughly $50,000 over the same two days — but that gain is unrealised, and the broker does not accept warehouse receipts for a VM call.
  • Day 3: settle $2,430 (−$20). VM = $20,000 back in.

Over the week the hedge behaved perfectly — flat price locked — while demanding up to $50,000 of cash at 24 hours' notice. That is the lesson: a correct hedge can still break a firm that has not arranged the cash to run it. Treasury must size a margin funding line to a plausible adverse move on the peak hedge book (e.g. a 2-sigma weekly move — two standard deviations, a bad-but-plausible week seen only a few times a year — on maximum lots), and the desk must know the line's headroom before adding positions.

Margin offsets. Clearing risk models margin the portfolio, not each lot: a short December against a long March (a spread) margins far below two outrights (an outright = a single-leg position in one month) because the legs offset; related contracts can receive inter-commodity credits. Practical consequences: rolls and switches are cheap to margin, and IM can jump when one leg of an offsetting pair closes — the surviving leg re-margins as an outright.

On the statement, this machinery appears as: initial margin requirement, variation margin (the day's cash sweep), and account equity (cash ± open MTM). Equity below requirement = margin call; the reconciliation habit from module 4 is what lets you trust these numbers enough to fund them same-day without argument.

The rest of this module

  1. Broker relationships and account structure
    Choosing and running FCM relationships: accounts, limits, agreements, give-ups, and why margin never nets across brokers.
  2. The full cost of a hedge
    Commissions, spread, margin funding, roll cost — pricing the insurance honestly.

Carry on with the course

The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Commodity & FX Hedging Operations.

Next module: Lifecycle — prompts, rolls, switches and close-out