Courses / Commodity & FX Hedging
Hedging without a futures market — cross-hedges and proxies
Optional module: what to do when your product has no futures contract, how to measure whether a proxy actually works, and how to report it honestly.
Lesson 1 · free to read
When there is no contract for what you trade
Futures exist for a few dozen commodities. Most physical products are not among them: many meats, most processed foods, speciality grains, many chemicals and minerals. A firm trading one of those still has price risk. It has four ways to deal with it, and they can be combined.
- A proxy future (a cross-hedge). Hedge with the futures contract of a related commodity whose price tends to move with yours. The relationship can be economic (the proxy is a major input, or a close substitute) or just statistical. Only the economic kind tends to survive.
- Hedge an input. If a large share of your cost is a traded commodity, such as feed grain, fuel or a base metal, hedging that input fixes part of your margin even if the selling price stays exposed.
- Hedge the currency only. An exporter paid in US dollars with costs in another currency often cannot hedge the product price, but can hedge the currency cleanly and cheaply with forwards. For many exporters this is the largest risk they can actually remove.
- Hedge commercially. Fixed-price back-to-back sales, contracts indexed to a published price, shorter contract terms, or price-adjustment clauses move the risk to a counterparty instead of the exchange.
How to choose a proxy. In order of importance:
- An economic link that explains why the prices move together. Without one, a correlation found in historical data can disappear without warning.
- Correlation of price changes, measured properly (lesson 2).
- Liquidity in the proxy contract, so the hedge can be put on and taken off.
- Currency and timing. A proxy priced in another currency adds currency risk, which then needs its own hedge. A proxy whose contract months do not match your trading calendar adds roll risk (module 6).
Be clear about what a cross-hedge is. You have swapped outright price risk for the risk that the two prices stop moving together. That residual is basis risk in its widest form, and module 9's case study on a cross-hedge that kept only about 39% of its protection shows how large it can be.
The rest of this module
- Measuring whether the proxy actually worksCorrelate changes, not levels. Size the hedge from volatility and correlation. Expect it to remove less risk than the correlation suggests.
- Running and reporting a cross-hedge honestlyMonitor the relationship, set a rule for when to stop, and never report a cross-hedge as 'hedged'.
Carry on with the course
The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Commodity & FX Hedging Operations.