Courses / Grain Trading, Supply Chain & Hedging

Beyond flat price — the risks a hedge does not remove

Basis, spread, quality, counterparty, logistics and currency. What is left after the futures are on.

Module 4 of 123 lessonsAbout 45 minQuiz: 6 questions
HedgePlan

Lesson 1 · free to read

Basis risk — what you swapped your price risk for

A merchant who buys priced grain and sells futures against it has not eliminated risk. They have converted flat-price risk into basis risk. The hedged position's P&L is now driven by:

basis = local cash price − futures price

Extension material is explicit on this: after hedging, the final value of the grain is still subject to fluctuations in local basis. Holbrook Working put it more sharply — hedging is "not a risk reduction technique, but speculation in the basis". Commercial firms hedge because they have a view on how the cash-futures spread will move, not because they are indifferent to price.

Four independent sources of basis risk, and a position ledger should be able to distinguish them:

  • Location — your elevator is not the exchange's delivery point. Freight, local supply and demand, and local storage capacity all drive a wedge.
  • Grade and quality — your physical grain is not the par-deliverable specification.
  • Time / maturity — you lift the hedge before the futures contract expires, so convergence never gets the chance to happen.
  • Commodity — you hedged with a different commodity's contract entirely (a cross-hedge), which is common where no contract exists for what you actually trade, and which typically retains a large fraction of the original risk.

Convergence, and when it fails. The reason basis is bounded at all is the threat of physical delivery: at expiry, cash and futures at the par delivery location should converge. When that mechanism breaks, basis can move to extraordinary levels — CBOT wheat delivery-period basis reached −$1.90/bu during a multi-year convergence failure.

The governance point. A report that says "100% hedged" is false comfort. It means flat-price exposure has been neutralised; it says nothing about how much basis exposure has been taken on, and basis is where a merchant's actual profit and loss lives.

The rest of this module

  1. Spread, quality and counterparty
    Three more risks, one of which is not detectable by any market data feed.
  2. Logistics, currency and the one that actually kills firms
    Freight, FX, and margin as a liquidity risk rather than a market risk.

Carry on with the course

The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Grain Trading, Supply Chain & Hedging Operations.

Next module: From truck to ticket — weights, grades and the discount schedule