Courses / Grain Trading, Supply Chain & Hedging
Beyond flat price — the risks a hedge does not remove
Basis, spread, quality, counterparty, logistics and currency. What is left after the futures are on.
Lesson 1 · free to read
Basis risk — what you swapped your price risk for
A merchant who buys priced grain and sells futures against it has not eliminated risk. They have converted flat-price risk into basis risk. The hedged position's P&L is now driven by:
basis = local cash price − futures price
Extension material is explicit on this: after hedging, the final value of the grain is still subject to fluctuations in local basis. Holbrook Working put it more sharply — hedging is "not a risk reduction technique, but speculation in the basis". Commercial firms hedge because they have a view on how the cash-futures spread will move, not because they are indifferent to price.
Four independent sources of basis risk, and a position ledger should be able to distinguish them:
- Location — your elevator is not the exchange's delivery point. Freight, local supply and demand, and local storage capacity all drive a wedge.
- Grade and quality — your physical grain is not the par-deliverable specification.
- Time / maturity — you lift the hedge before the futures contract expires, so convergence never gets the chance to happen.
- Commodity — you hedged with a different commodity's contract entirely (a cross-hedge), which is common where no contract exists for what you actually trade, and which typically retains a large fraction of the original risk.
Convergence, and when it fails. The reason basis is bounded at all is the threat of physical delivery: at expiry, cash and futures at the par delivery location should converge. When that mechanism breaks, basis can move to extraordinary levels — CBOT wheat delivery-period basis reached −$1.90/bu during a multi-year convergence failure.
The governance point. A report that says "100% hedged" is false comfort. It means flat-price exposure has been neutralised; it says nothing about how much basis exposure has been taken on, and basis is where a merchant's actual profit and loss lives.
The rest of this module
- Spread, quality and counterpartyThree more risks, one of which is not detectable by any market data feed.
- Logistics, currency and the one that actually kills firmsFreight, FX, and margin as a liquidity risk rather than a market risk.
Carry on with the course
The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Grain Trading, Supply Chain & Hedging Operations.
Next module: From truck to ticket — weights, grades and the discount schedule