Courses / Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting

Hedge accounting — the hedge and the trade in the same period

A good hedge can make the accounts swing more, not less. Hedge accounting, or fair-valuing both sides, is how they line up.

Module 7 of 73 lessonsAbout 50 minQuiz: 6 questions
AccountHedge

Lesson 1 · free to read

The accounting mismatch

A hedge is designed so that a loss on one side is matched by a gain on the other. The accounts often do not see it that way, because the two sides are measured differently:

  • Futures and other derivatives are carried at fair value, and every change in value goes to the profit and loss as it happens. Daily variation margin makes this concrete: the cash moves every day.
  • A forecast purchase (goods you plan to buy) is not recorded at all until it happens.
  • A fixed-price purchase contract not yet delivered is usually not recorded either, if it is held for the business's own use (Lesson 2).
  • Inventory is carried at cost (or the lower of cost and net realisable value), so a rise in the market price is not recognised until the goods are sold.

Worked. In September a roaster plans to buy 100 t of beans in December, and fixes its price risk by buying futures equivalent to 100 t at $2,000/t. At the 31 October year-end the futures are at $2,150: a gain of $15,000. The physical beans the roaster will buy have also gone up, but it has not bought them yet.

Without hedge accounting:

  • October (this year's accounts): a $15,000 gain in the P&L.
  • December: the roaster closes the futures at 2,170 (a further $2,000 gain) and buys the beans at $2,180/t: inventory $218,000.
  • Next year, when the beans are sold: cost of sales of $218,000, $18,000 more than planned.

The hedge worked: the business paid about $2,010/t all-in, close to the $2,000 it locked. But the accounts show a windfall this year and a squeezed margin next year. To a reader of the accounts, or a bank testing covenants, the hedge looks like speculation.

There are two ways to make the accounts reflect the economics. Lesson 2 covers the one large traders often use; Lesson 3 the one processors usually need.

The rest of this module

  1. Own use, and the broker-trader route
    Whether a physical contract is a derivative depends on how the business uses such contracts.
  2. Hedge accounting: designation, cash flow hedges and fair value hedges
    Document the hedge at inception, park the effective gain in equity, and release it when the hedged item hits the P&L.

Carry on with the course

The other lessons and the quiz are in the course itself, where your progress is saved and counts towards the certificate: Deal Costing, Margin & Trade Accounting.